| Name | Died | Age | ||||
| Adam Dyer (No 1) | 1855 - May 9 | 22 | ||||
| John Roberts (No 2) | 1855 - May 15 | ? | ||||
| Monson W Barnard (No 3) | 1855 - May 19 | ? | ||||
| Elizabeth Hill (No 4) (wife of Ambrose) |
1860 - May 20 | 51 | ||||
| Kennis Fergerson (No 5) (photo) | 1864 - May 20 | 22 | ||||
| Antone Domingo (No 6) | 1872 - November 1 | 22 | ||||
| George G Hallett (No 8) (son of Nathaniel & Mary D Hallett) |
1872 - November 26 | 31 | ||||
| Tamsin Manuel (No 9) (photo) | 1872 - November 27 | 73 | ||||
| Mary Rogers (No 7) (arrived in Provincetown November 2, 1872) |
1872 - November 8 | 25 | ||||
| Frank Sofrine (No 10) (photo) (alias Small) |
1872 - December 24 | ? | ||||
| Manuel Terceira (No 11) | 1872 - December 24 | ? | ||||
| Thomas Bussell (No 14) (arrived in Provincetown May 17, 1873) |
1873 - May 28 | ? | ||||
| William H Butler (No 12) | 1873 - January 7 | ? | ||||
| John A McDonald (No 13) (a Scottsman) |
1873 - January 8 | ? |